Showing posts with label espionage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label espionage. Show all posts
Thursday, July 25, 2024
Monday, July 15, 2024
Cross your fingers
https://x.com/NormEisen/status/1812855922957422821/history
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.
UPDATE 12:44 pm:
Here's the more harrowing thought, as mentioned in the piece by Elie Mystal below: They could put her on the 11th Circuit, thereby diluting the bench that has stood now as a check on her Trump favoritism.
UPDATE 04:42 pm:
That would take some other party. The Democrats are constitutionally incapable.Two weeks ago, the Supreme Court proved that it valued Trump over the rule of law when it granted him absolute immunity. Today, Aileen Cannon proved that she values Trump over the rule of law when she dismissed the charges against him. The rule of law is not failing, it has failed.
[...]
The authority of special counsels has been challenged by countless defendants across multiple presidential administrations from the case before—from Ronald Reagan’s to Bill Clinton’s. But courts have roundly rejected these challenges on the basis that the power to appoint special counsels is widely recognized by statutes and precedent. Until now, that is.
[...]
Federalist Society judges generally and Trump appointed judges specifically are not serious people. They don’t give a damn about what the rules have been or should be. The only laws, precedents, and norms they believe in are the ones that help them achieve their current political goals. [...] Trump judges understand that judges make the rules, and they consistently act like it.
[...]
Trump was going to escape these charges the moment Cannon was appointed as his judge, and everybody who has an honest understanding of what Trump judges do for a living knew it.
[...]
Her job is secure unless someone can find a majority of votes in the House and 67 votes in the Senate to impeach and convict her. So long as the Republicans she aides hold any shred of power, getting fired from her job is not something that Cannon ever has to worry about.
[...]
Jack Smith, of course, has no choice but to play the losing hand he’s been dealt to the bitter end. As to how he does that, he has two options. First and most likely, he can appeal Cannon’s dismissal to the 11th Circuit. The circuit court will likely stay the dismissal pending a full hearing on the merits, at which point Trump’s lawyers will appeal the 11th Circuit ruling to the Supreme Court. There, six judges who have already declared Trump immune from accountability for official acts while president will have to determine if their fear of Trump being held accountable for crimes he committed after he was president is so great that they need to functionally destroy the special counsel rule in order to get him off once again. Of course, all of those determinations will happen after the election, and if Trump wins that election, the whole issue becomes moot anyway.
[...]
If you take Garland at his word and believe that he appointed Smith to avoid the political optics of a presidential cabinet member prosecuting a case against their administration’s defeated rival, those optics are probably even worse now, as Trump is about to be nominated by his party, and the case has no chance of being resolved before the next election. All of which means that Garland is unlikely to take the case under his own authority, even though that is the most expedient and effective legal move.
[...]
It is worth noting that the desire to appear apolitical is what pushed Garland to appoint a special counsel, which then opened the legal door for a partisan hack judge to make a political ruling focused on that appointment, instead of the underlying case. Maybe the next time Democrats hold power (if there is a next time) they could, I don’t know, do what is right instead of worrying about the political optics of it all?
Elie Mystal @ The Nation
Going to the 11th. This will at least be interesting.[T]he real failure of Democratic Party leadership, and most left-of-center folks, in the Trump era has been the unsupported belief that the institutions and especially the courts can and would hold.
That was simply never going to be the case. Institutions cannot work if only one side agrees to be bound by them.
[...]
Once again, Trump has won his battle against accountability, and the people telling you otherwise are selling you something (and probably asking for you to donate money to their campaigns).
Sadly, it won't matter. These guys don't mind being hypocritical.
Sunday, July 7, 2024
Thursday, June 27, 2024
Tuesday, June 25, 2024
Cannon walking the edge
She doesn't want to get slapped down by the 11th Circuit again.
Cannon's ruling doesn't mean a lot. Other than that she can stay on the case and help Trump in all her other many ways. Like granting a Franks hearing on bullshit claims.*
And...
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.
But he got his hearing, didn't he?[Trump's lawyers] contended the [Mar-A-Lago search] warrant was unconstitutionally vague and the FBI affidavit, used to convince the magistrate judge to find there was probable cause for a crime at the club, contained contextual omissions.
[...]
[In a hearing today,] Aileen Cannon suggested she considered the warrant was sufficiently specific about what items FBI agents could seize at Mar-a-Lago, and told Trump’s lawyers the omissions would have made no difference on whether there was probable cause.
[...]
The attempt by Trump to suppress the Mar-a-Lago evidence came through a request for a Franks hearing, where a judge applies a four-part test to decide whether false or misleading statements in the affidavit meant the evidence obtained through that search needed to be suppressed.
[...]
The evidence Trump’s lawyers presented was limited to complaints that the FBI agent omitted the fact that some top FBI officials preferred a consensual search of Mar-a-Lago, the FBI tying the need for a warrant to the National Archives, and Trump did not need a security clearance as president.
[...]
Trump’s request was ambitious because the legal threshold to get a Franks hearing is onerous. Trump needed to make a “substantial preliminary showing” that the affidavit had parts that were recklessly false.
The Guardian
Cannon's ruling doesn't mean a lot. Other than that she can stay on the case and help Trump in all her other many ways. Like granting a Franks hearing on bullshit claims.*
And...
I doubt it's much of a struggle.[On Tuesday morning, at a sealed hearing, Trump asked Cannon] to revoke prosecutors’ access to memos made by his ex-lawyer [Evan Corcoran] that became key evidence of his efforts to obstruct the investigation.
[...]
The sweeping request could have far-reaching consequences since the memos – with, for example, Trump asking whether they could ignore the subpoena, or a later suggestion to “pluck” out some classified documents instead of returning them to the FBI – are the strongest evidence of Trump’s obstructive intent.
Even if the judge excludes only some of the passages, it could dramatically undercut the strength of the obstruction case.
In the worst case for prosecutors, their evidence of Trump’s obstructive intent could be reduced to CCTV footage of boxes being moved at Mar-a-Lago by his co-defendants Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira, logs of Trump’s calls with Nauta, and testimony about Nauta’s movements.
Trump faces a struggle to get Cannon to overturn the initial ruling by the then chief US district judge Beryl Howell in Washington DC. But Cannon has previously ruled for Trump on evidentiary disputes, most recently removing a paragraph in the indictment about Trump waving around a classified map.
The Guardian
She'll do her best to help them out.The original thinking on Trump’s legal team was to concede that some of the memos could conceivably be subject to the crime-fraud exception, such as when Corcoran told Trump he would be searching the storage room, and Corcoran’s confirmation about when he intended to return to Mar-a-Lago.
Trump’s lawyers have since rejected that approach, reasoning that any concession could give the judge an off-ramp to wholly deny their request, whereas asking for all the memos to be struck would be a stronger argument and lead the judge to strike even some of the memos.
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.
*UPDATE 06/27/2024: It seems Trump DIDN'T get the Franks hearing. I misunderstood.
Tuesday, June 11, 2024
Meanwhile, in more Cannonigans*...
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.
*Coined by Andy McCabe.
UPDATE 06/12/2024:
She's been watching Trump/MAGA reaction to Trump's Manhattan trial and verdict in which they cry about the fact that the jury was allowed to individually choose among three means of committing the crime to come to their unanimous guilty verdict.
She won't be allowed to let this "requirement" stand.
Monday, June 10, 2024
Cannon makes a decision!
In the end, it won't matter if he's elected. And she's doing her best to get him there.
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.
UPDATE 06/11/2024:
Friday, May 24, 2024
Special counsel files a new motion
Following Trump's incredible and outrageous claim that the FBI (at Biden's behest) tried to assassinate him.
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.Jack Smith opens with The Government moves to modify defendant Donald J. Trump’s conditions of release, to make clear that he may not make statements that pose a significant, imminent, and foreseeable danger to law enforcement agents participating in the investigation and prosecution of this case.
He then informs the court that he met and conferred with Trump’s lawyers, who oppose his motion, and also said they object to the timing - seeing as it’s a holiday weekend.
[...]
Jack Smith goes on to say Those statements create a grossly misleading impression about the intentions and conduct of federal law enforcement agents—falsely suggesting that they were complicit in a plot to assassinate him—and expose those agents, some of whom will be witnesses at trial, to the risk of threats, violence, and harassment. The Court has an “independent obligation to protect the integrity of this judicial proceeding,” ECF No. 101, and should take steps immediately to halt this dangerous campaign to smear law enforcement.
[...]
As Trump is well aware, the FBI took extraordinary care to execute the search warrant unobtrusively and without needless confrontation: they scheduled the search of Mar-a-Lago for a time when he and his family would be away; they planned to coordinate with Trump’s attorney, Secret Service agents, and Mar-a-Lago staff before and during the execution of the warrant; and they planned for contingencies—which, in fact, never came to pass—about with whom to communicate if Trump were to arrive on the scene.
As part of this planning, the FBI used a form that contains standard and unobjectionable language setting out the Department of Justice’s use-of-force policy, which prohibits the use of deadly force except “when the officer has a reasonable belief that the subject of such force poses an imminent danger of death or serious physical injury to the officer or to another person.” The inclusion of that policy is routine practice to restrict the use of force, and it is attached to countless warrants across the country.
Trump, however, has distorted the standard inclusion of the policy limiting the use of deadly force by mischaracterizing it as a claim that the FBI “WAS AUTHORIZED TO SHOOT ME,” was “just itching to do the unthinkable,” and was “locked & loaded ready to take me out & put my family in danger.”
[...]
A condition of release that prohibits the defendant from making statements posing a significant, imminent, and foreseeable danger to law enforcement agents participating in the investigation and prosecution of this case is warranted and necessary here. Such a prohibition will also minimize further prejudice caused by the defendant directing false and inflammatory messages regarding the facts of this case to potential jurors who may be summoned by the Court for jury service in this matter.
[...]
On February 22, 2024, Trump filed under seal a motion to suppress evidence obtained through the search of Mar-a-Lago. In setting forth what he described as the relevant facts, Trump stated that the Operations Form “contained a ‘Policy Statement’ regarding ‘Use Of Deadly Force,’ which stated, for example, ‘Law enforcement officers of the Department of Justice may use deadly force when necessary [sic] . . . .’” Although Trump included the warrant and Operations Form as exhibits to his motion, the motion misquoted the Operations Form by omitting the crucial word “only” before “when necessary,” without any ellipsis reflecting the omission.
Mueller, She Wrote
Tuesday, May 7, 2024
And there it is
UPDATE 05/08/2024:
And it says "partial".
UPDATE 05/13/2024:
Meanwhile in Florida
Just as well simply dismiss the case. Which she may do in the end.
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.
Sunday, May 5, 2024
Smith team misstep
Doesn't matter. This will be seized upon by Trump and Cannon both to further denigrate the case against Trump.Special counsel Jack Smith’s team acknowledged Friday that some evidence in the prosecution of former President Donald Trump for hoarding classified documents at his Florida home may not be in the same sequence FBI agents found it when they swept into the Mar-a-Lago compound with a search warrant in August 2022.
The concession from prosecutors in a court filing Friday afternoon came after attorneys for one of Trump’s co-defendants asked for a delay in the case because the defense lawyers were having trouble determining precisely where particular documents had come from in the 33 boxes the FBI seized almost two years ago.
In their filing, prosecutors acknowledged the government had previously — and incorrectly — told U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon that the boxes remained “in their original, intact form as seized,” other than a decision to replace classified documents with placeholder sheets.
[...]
“There are some boxes where the order of items within that box is not the same as in the associated scans,” prosecutors wrote.
[...]
Prosecutors claim the discrepancies in the sequence of the records is of no significance to the criminal case filed in June 2023. Smith’s lawyers say the apparent jumble took place despite various precautions, including having an FBI agent present while an outside vendor scanned the documents so that Trump’s attorneys could see what was seized.
[...]
[Also], the boxes contain items smaller than standard paper such as index cards, books, and stationary [sic], which shift easily when the boxes are carried, especially because many of the boxes are not full,” prosecutors Jay Bratt, Julie Edelstein and David Harbach wrote.
[...]
Prosecutors say despite the reordering, each box still contains precisely the same material it had in it when it was seized.
Of course he did.“The investigative team used classified cover sheets for that purpose, until the FBI ran out because there were so many classified documents, at which point the team began using blank sheets with handwritten notes indicating the classification level of the document(s) seized,” the prosecutors wrote.
Later, they said, the handwritten notes were replaced with more formal placeholder sheets, but some of the handwritten ones may have been left in the boxes as well, complicating efforts to link a placeholder to a specific classified document.
[...]
In a post on his Trump Social site Friday, Trump painted the disclosures at catastrophic for the government’s case.
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.Smith “and his team committed blatant Evidence Tampering by mishandling the very Boxes they used as a pretext to bring this Fake Case,” Trump said, accusing prosecutors of “deeply illegal” actions that should trigger dismissal of all charges.
UPDATE 05/07/2024:
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Meanwhile in the documents case
...but hey, do what you want...you will anyway.Former President Trump brushed off warnings he could be charged for keeping classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago residence, promising to pardon one of his now co-defendants if charges were filed, according to new court documents.
[...]
The witness, identified only at Person 16 in the documents, told Trump he should cooperate with federal investigators looking for classified documents, saying doing so could prevent him from being indicted.
“Whatever you have, give everything back. Let them come here and get everything,” the witness said they told Trump. “Don’t give them a noble reason to indict you, because they will.”
But Trump seemed unphased.
[...]
The witness refused to have their conversation with the FBI recorded out of fear of reprisal.
[...]
The interview counters a defense from Trump that there was a standard order to declassify anything the former president had, with the witness saying they heard that for the first time only after Trump was facing charges.
The witness said they urged Trump multiple times to return the records being sought then by the National Archives, telling Trump something to the effect of it “was not worth all that aggravation.”
The witness also said they had urged Trump’s children to give him the same warning.
[...]
The witness said Nauta was told by those close to Trump that the documents case was politically motivated and “much ado about nothing” and that even if he faced charges for lying to the bureau, Trump would pardon him in 2024.
The Hill
UPDATE 04/24/2024:
Thursday, April 4, 2024
Wednesday, April 3, 2024
Smith answers Cannon's inane request
We can only hope.Special Counsel Jack Smith issued a scorching response to a request made by Judge Aileen Cannon, who demanded that Government and Donald Trump submit a set of hypothetical jury instructions to two completely erroneous premises that lacked a fundamental understanding of the issues at center of the stolen documents case.
[...]
Smith asserts that the proposed jury instructions would lead to confusion and potential miscarriages of justice. By directing the jury to determine the classification of documents under the PRA, the instructions conflate a factual determination with a legal one, thereby muddying the waters of the case.
[...]
The crux of the issue lies in the interpretation of the Presidential Records Act (PRA) and its relevance to the charges faced by Donald Trump. The Government argues that the distinction between "personal" and "Presidential" records under the PRA should not determine whether the former President's possession of highly classified documents is authorized under the Espionage Act. Smith explains that the PRA should play no role in the jury instructions regarding the elements of the Espionage Act.
[...]
He asserts that if the Court wrongly concludes that the legal premise represents a correct formulation of the law, it must inform the parties well in advance of the trial. This is crucial to allow the Government the opportunity to consider appellate review before jeopardy attaches, laying the groundwork to seek mandamus against Judge Cannon, which could ultimately end in Cannon getting booted from the case.
Meidas Touch
Smith provides a detailed account of Trump's actions following his departure from office, demonstrating a consistent acknowledgment that the documents were presidential records.
[...]
Smith explains that Trump's invocation of the PRA is not grounded in any decisions he made during his presidency. Instead, it is portrayed as a post hoc justification concocted after leaving the White House. Smith contends that there is no basis in law or fact for this legal presumption and urges the Court to reject Trump's efforts to inject the PRA into the case.
[...]
He argues that authorization to possess classified information is governed by Executive Order 13526, not the PRA, and that Trump's purported designation holds no legal weight in the context of unauthorized possession.
[...]
Smith provides alternative jury instructions that adhere to the correct legal framework. These instructions clarify that unauthorized possession of classified information is determined by whether an individual holds a security clearance, has a need-to-know basis, and complies with safeguarding regulations outlined in Executive Order 13526. In both hypothetical scenarios, the Special Counsel makes clear that the instructions, as defined by Judge Cannon, would be incorrect. In his conclusion, Smith once again emphasizes that he will be forced to take action should Judge Cannon not reject Trump's erroneous legal premise, which should have never been considered in the first place.
Smith concludes: "If, however, the Court does not reject that erroneous legal premise, it should make that decision clear now, long before jeopardy attaches, to allow the Government the opportunity to seek appellate review. "
UPDATE 03:55 pm: In plainer English...
Some say she's cleverly evil; some say she's incompetent. I don't know, but either is bad for the country.Rather than take on Cannon’s cockamamie assignment, Smith laid out accurate jury instructions based on the actual charges and law.
Cannon had ordered the parties to “engage with” the Trump team’s recurrent misinterpretation of the Presidential Records Act, which has no legal bearing on the case. Her order also depended on an account of the facts — namely, that Trump may have magically converted all the classified government records at issue into his personal property as he left the White House — that has always been beyond incredible.
In effect, Cannon was ordering the Justice Department to assume that the world is flat and then map a route from Atlantis to Arcadia.
But the order wasn’t just daffy; it was pernicious.
[H]er “Alice in Wonderland” antics seemed designed to avoid issuing a ruling that prosecutors could appeal while also setting the stage for her to adopt Trump’s ridiculous claims after a jury has been impaneled.
That could be a fatal blow to Smith’s case. Once a jury is selected, even a ridiculous order can bring a prosecution to a hard stop because the Constitution’s double jeopardy clause precludes retrial. It would be the judicial equivalent of a perfect crime.
LA Times/Harry Litman
I vote for the latter.Cannon has repeatedly indulged silly arguments from Team Trump while eating up weeks and months that prosecutors — and voters — don’t have. She has taken a cut-and-dried case based on overwhelming evidence and made it a long shot to be tried this year, when it matters most.
Her conduct [favoring Trump with delays while avoiding definitive rulings that Smith’s team could readily appeal] has raised the question of when and how Smith could ask the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals to remove her from the case. That would be a heavy lift, and yet Cannon’s earlier bungling of a search warrant in the case was so extreme that another grievous error could justify such an unusual remedy.
[...]
Cannon’s precious thought experiment was not only wrongheaded; it was a dereliction of the court’s basic responsibility to rule on the parties’ motions.
[...]
The government’s 24-page answer states flatly that the judge’s “legal premise is wrong, and a jury instruction … that reflects that premise would distort the trial.” Under the usual rules of discourse between judge and litigants (and especially federal prosecutors), that’s pretty cheeky.
[...]
Smith’s team also put the need for a speedy trial in particularly clear terms: “Whatever the court decides, it must resolve these crucial threshold legal questions promptly. Failure to do so would improperly jeopardize the Government’s right to a fair trial.”
[...]
“The Government must have the opportunity to consider appellate reThe Smith team then made its most important and aggressive move by noting that when judges have issued clearly erroneous jury instructions that doom prosecutions, “courts have permitted the government to obtain writs of mandamus.”
Even buried in a parenthetical as it is, the word “mandamus” jumps off the page as a threat to seek an extraordinary intervention by the appellate court. Smith has laid down the gauntlet, telling Cannon in no uncertain terms that if she doesn’t move to resolve Trump’s frivolous arguments well ahead of trial, he will bring a writ of mandamus to the 11th Circuit along with a motion to recuse her from the case.view well before jeopardy attaches.”
[...]
[T]his brief is the special counsel’s most important in the case since the indictment. Under the circumstances, it’s the strongest possible move to speed the prosecution to a trial before the election. Either Cannon will move the case along, or the department will try to remove her from it.
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
Cannon order
Well, yes. She's determined to get him off the hook.The judge overseeing Donald Trump’s classified-documents case issued an unusual order late Monday regarding jury instructions at the end of the trial — even though she has not yet ruled on when the trial will be held, or a host of other issues.
U.S. District Court Judge Aileen M. Cannon instructed lawyers to file proposed jury instructions by April 2 on two topics that are related to defense motions to have the indictment dismissed outright.
[...]
[S]he sounded skeptical that Trump’s attack on the Espionage Act, or his embrace of the Presidential Records Act, were strong enough to save the former president and likely 2024 Republican White House nominee from a criminal trial. At the same time, she suggested that aspects of Trump’s arguments might be valid enough to come into play during jury instructions.
Juries are instructed on how to weigh the evidence just before they begin deliberating, so Cannon’s focus on this topic suggests she is not only thinking ahead to a trial of the former president, but already zeroing in on the end, rather than the beginning, of such a proceeding.
WaPo
WTF?Her two-page order, however, also suggests an openness to some of the defense’s claims that the Presidential Records Act allows Trump or other presidents to declare highly classified documents to be their own personal property. National security law experts say that is not what the law says, or how it has been interpreted over decades by the courts.
[...]
Cannon asked the prosecutors and defense attorneys to consider two different hypothetical situations, writing: “the parties must engage with the following competing scenarios and offer alternative draft text that assumes each scenario to be a correct formulation of the law.”
And Trump's lawyers will undoubtedly continue to file one ridiculous motion after another knowing she'll grant hearings and arguments on them all, delaying the trial indefinitely.Confusingly, she added in a footnote that any “separation of powers or immunity concerns shall be included in this discussion if relevant.” Immunity is a topic for judges to decide, not juries, so it was not immediately clear what that language in Cannon’s order meant.
[...]
[The] second hypothetical [whether Trump could categorize the records in question as personal] would appear to be one in which Trump seemingly could not be convicted under almost any set of facts of improperly possessing classified documents.
[...]
After the hearing last week, Cannon issued a short order saying that while some of Trump’s arguments about the Espionage Act warrant “serious consideration,” she thought it was too early to dismiss charges based on disagreements over the definition of some terms in the World War I-era law.
At the same time, she suggested Trump could raise the issue later “in connection with jury-instruction briefing and/or other appropriate motions,” an invitation that appears to have led to Monday’s order.
[...]
She could schedule additional motion hearings at any time.
Fingers crossed.
UPDATE 03:18 pm:
UPDATE 03/20/2024:
Oh, gee, what a surprise.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


















































