Caveat: the article comes from the American Action Network - described as a "center-right" group founded by a Republican senator and a Republican fundraiser/strategist. Specifically, the author was a senior policy adviser for John McCain's run for the presidency, and members of the group include Jeb Bush and the wife of Mitch McConnell.
Let them eat cake.[T]he Department of Labor (DOL) has finalized its proposed "fiduciary rule" – the Obama administration's regulatory onslaught on retirement saving advice. Hiding behind the high-minded notion of a "fiduciary" standard that purports to put customers' interests first is a regulation that is expensive and onerous, and not a favor to investors in the end.
Most, 86.2 percent, of the $7.3 trillion in retirement assets is in commission-based accounts. That means that instead of paying high fees directly to the adviser for his or her advice, the adviser is taking a smaller fee that is a portion of the gains in the account. When DOL's fiduciary rule is enacted, each of those accounts – totaling $6.3 trillion – will be moved to a fee-based account. Even with a fee of just 1.2 percent that's $75.6 billion in duplicative fees on American retirement accounts, or about $1500 per household. This cost is an unneeded tax on people saving for retirement who should not be forced into fee-based accounts that they don't want.
As it turns out, these may be the lucky "winners." A majority (51 percent) of retirement accounts have balances less than $25,000, and, for small funds, it will simply make no sense to pay the fees. These retirement savers will be cut off entirely from retirement saving advice.
[...]
The fiduciary rule is a mistake. At best it is a well-intentioned overreach in which the desire to improve the investment advice for a few means no advice for the masses. At worst, it is a classic case of burdensome, top-down regulation that ends up harming the very consumers that it is purported to help
CNBC
This has the scent of the great Affordable Health Care Act.
No comments:
Post a Comment